The Roots of the United States Constitution
The United States Constitution is often depicted as
emerging wholly from the minds of the Founding Fathers, like Athena from the
brow of Zeus. In fact the Founders were keenly aware of Greek, Roman and
British history, and of all the writings of the Enlightenment philosophers, so
they took the best ideas from these sources and avoided the failures of the
remainder.
Starting with Ancient Athens, the Founding Fathers
were very skeptical of Athenian democracy, where the assembly of citizens had
the power to appoint generals and vote to initiate war. Aristotle wrote,
"There are thus three forms of government: monarchy, aristocracy, and
constitutional republic. The perverted forms of these are tyranny, oligarchy
and democracy. The constitutional
republic is regarded as the best attainable form of government, especially as
it secures that predominance of a large middle class, which is the chief basis
of permanence in a state." Another factor in Plato's and Aristotle's
rejection of Athenian-style democracy was Socrates death sentence by the
Athenian Assembly. James Madison pointed to this in the Federalist Paper No. 55
as follows, "Had every Athenian citizen been a Socrates, every Athenian
assembly would still have been a mob". The result of the Founders'
distrust of the immediate passions of citizens is very clear by the buffers
built into the Constitution, especially when it comes to the selection of the
President.
The next historical root of the Constitution is
Rome. Rome had both an Assembly and a Senate, this was the beginning of a
bicameral legislature. It split the executive power between two Consuls, one which
acted as field general for their never ending warfare and the other to administer
the government. However there was a weakness with the Roman Republic and it was
the generals were given too much authority. Sulla, Marius and Caesar had marched
on Rome to claim power for themselves so to prevent this from happening the
Founders decided to give the executive power in one elected person - a civilian
head over the military.
The third root of the Constitution was from British
History. From this we have two important additions:
* The Writ of Habeas Corpus from the Magna Carta (1215
AD)
Habeas Corpus, literally in Latin "you have the body" is a term that
represents an important right granted to individuals in America. Basically, a
writ of habeas corpus is a judicial mandate requiring that a prisoner be
brought before the court to determine whether the government has the right to
continue detaining them. The individual being held or their representative can
petition the court for such a writ.
According to Article One of the Constitution, the
right to a writ of habeas corpus can only be suspended "in cases of
rebellion or invasion the public safety." Habeas corpus was suspended
during the Civil War and Reconstruction, in parts of South Carolina during the
fight against the Ku Klux Klan, and during the War on Terror.
* The charge of treason requires two witnesses. This
was dramatized by the trial.
In
law, treason is the crime that covers some of the more extreme acts against
one's sovereign or nation. In English law, high treason was punishable by being
hanged, drawn and quartered (men) or burnt at the stake (women), or beheading
(royalty and nobility). Treason was the only crime which attracted those
penalties (until they were abolished in 1790, 1814 and 1973 respectively)
The
United States Constitution was written to protect the people
of the United States from its own government, as well as to keep the government
from having total control over the people. There were many events and
historical documents such as The Magna Carta, Mayflower Compact, The Declaration
of Independence, Articles of Confederation, and Federalist Papers which were
influential in developing the United States Constitution.
The Founding Fathers searched for historical documents
to inspire them while writing the Constitution. One such document was the Magna
Carta, which was originally created in 1215. This document was influential to the framers
and the writers of the Constitution by acknowledging that no man is above the
law. The Magna Carta also established the rights of the individual, which is
the legacy of the Bill of Rights. The Magna Carta stood against Tyranny and
protected the individual freedoms of its people.
In 1620, the
Mayflower Compact created laws and offices which aided the people. It
brought about the Lockean idea of government, which was created by John Locke.
John Locke believed that Monarchy was a false form of government. He believed
that liberty and political order could co-exist and that men should work for
what he receives. He also believed that men are subject to Gods laws. His ideas
influenced that the Constitution would be written for One Nation under God,
that men are created equal and have the right to "The Pursuit of life,
liberty and Happiness." The Mayflower Compact brought forth the idea that
all men are created by God and belong to God, and the “government” should be
separate from mans religious freedoms.
The
Declaration of Independence had a very strong influence on the
writing of the Constitution. The idea that everyone is created equal was
included the Declaration just as it was in the Mayflower Compact. The
Declaration secured these rights by stating that the government DID NOT have the power over the people,
but rather THE PEOPLE ARE THE GOVERNMENT. If the government
becomes corrupt, the people have the authority to change or abolish it and
start over with a new government. The Declaration also broke the ties
between America and Great Britain influencing the Constitution by creating
principals of a fair and just government.
The
Articles of Confederation influenced the writing of the
constitution in many ways. Even though they did not create a strong National
Government, they gave each state the
rights to their own government and independence. The Constitution allows
states to govern, however the Federal Government monitors and controls the
states to be sure that the states are working for the people and not against
them. The Articles of Confederation also gave the states the rights to their
own courts and laws for which each state would enforce. Congress did not have
the power to tax people, which influenced the writers of the constitution to
allow congress to collect and impose taxed fairly so that the government could
function for the people.
The
Federalist Papers consisted of eighty-five articles
asking for the ratification of the Constitution. The primary influence that the
Federalist Papers had on the development of the constitution was that the
authors of the letters wanted to assure limited government control over the
people. They wanted the government to belong to the people, and the government
officials to work for the people with their best interests at heart. The
Federalist papers also offered warnings to those writing the Constitution,
making them aware that big government could easily become corrupt. They wanted
the Constitution to be a fair document that would protect the people and the
Nation.
The
Northwest Ordinance (1787) The Northwest Ordinance was one
of the few accomplishments of the Articles government. It dictated how the western territories would
be governed and specified “equal footing” terms on which they would be
eventually admitted as states. It was an enlightened piece of legislation: the
ordinance banned slavery in the territory, promised decent treatment of Native
Americans, made the first national provision for public education, and
safeguarded freedom of religion and other important liberties.
As we have learned several different events and documents were influential
in the process of creating the United States Constitution, which was created
for the people by the people to insure the Freedom for all Americans to pursue
life, liberty, and happiness. The Framers of the Constitution used the
influence of The Magna Carta, The Mayflower Compact, Declaration of
Independence, Articles of Confederation, the Federalist Papers and the
Northwest Ordinance when writing the Constitution. They used these influences
to protect the people of America from its own government, and ensure that every
man and woman could enjoy the freedoms that come with being One Nation Under
God.
Very nice. In the courses I teach, I frequently trace Constitutional roots to the Enlightenment era. Good stuff.
ReplyDeleteThanks for your comment. I'm glad you enjoyed the post. Linda, you're an excellent writer. :)
ReplyDelete